What Are Performance Share Units (PSUs)? A Complete Guide for Executives and Tech Leaders

Roadmap to Performance Shares
Quick summary

In today's corporate world, compensation isn't just about a salary and bonus. For senior executives, tech leaders, and top-performing professionals, a growing share of wealth comes from equity-based incentives, and one type of award is increasingly defining how performance and pay intersect: performance shares.

Once limited to CEOs and top-tier leadership, performance-based stock grants are now appearing further down the organizational chart, particularly in fast-growing public companies and later-stage private firms seeking to align rewards with long-term success.

But what exactly are performance shares? How do they work? How are they taxed? And most importantly, how should you plan around them?

This article breaks down the structure, value, and planning implications of performance share units (PSUs) and related awards so you can make the most of your company's long-term incentive plan.

🔍 What Are Performance Shares?

Performance shares (often called performance stock units or PSUs) are a form of equity compensation that rewards you only if specific performance goals are achieved over a defined period, usually three years.

Unlike restricted stock units (RSUs), which typically vest based on continued employment, performance shares are earned only when your company meets specific financial or market-based targets.

In other words, no results, no shares.

Common performance metrics include:

  • Earnings per share (EPS) growth
  • Total shareholder return (TSR), often relative to peers
  • Revenue growth or profit margins
  • Return on equity (ROE) or return on assets (ROA)
  • Strategic milestones, such as product launches or regulatory approvals

When the performance period ends, the company measures actual results against the preset goals. Depending on that outcome, you'll receive anywhere from 0% to 200% of your target shares (sometimes even higher, depending on the plan).

⚙️ How Performance Shares Work

Step 1: Grant and Target Award

You're granted a target number of performance shares, say 2,000, as part of your company's Long-Term Incentive Plan (LTIP). These shares aren't issued yet. Instead, they're a potential award based on future performance.

Step 2: Performance Measurement

Your company defines one or more metrics, for example:

  • 3-year EPS growth of 10% annually, and
  • Relative TSR at or above the 75th percentile of peer companies

Each metric may carry a weighting (e.g., 50% EPS, 50% TSR).

Step 3: Payout Formula

At the end of the 3 years, results are measured.

  • Below threshold: No shares vest.
  • At target: You earn 100% of your target shares (2,000 in this example).
  • Above target: You may earn more, often up to 150%–200% of the target.

The performance curve is designed to scale rewards in proportion to achievement.

Step 4: Delivery and Settlement

If goals are met, shares are issued (or “settled”) to you; sometimes after an additional time-based vesting period to encourage retention.

The shares are then taxed as ordinary income when they're delivered.

🧩 Key Design Features of Performance Share Plans

Every company's plan is unique, but several common design elements shape the value and risk of performance share grants.

1. Measurement Period

Usually three years, aligning with the company's long-term strategic plan. Some firms use rolling cycles, granting new PSUs annually with overlapping measurement windows.

2. Performance Metrics

Metrics can be absolute (achieve X% EPS growth) or relative (beat the industry median TSR). Many companies use a combination to balance internal execution and market competitiveness.

3. Sliding Scale or Leverage

Performance shares often include a payout range, with scaling between the threshold, target, and maximum performance levels. This creates both upside potential and downside risk.

Performance Level Achievement Payout % of Target
Below Threshold < 80% of goal 0%
Target 100% of goal 100%
Maximum 120%+ of goal 200%

4. Post-Performance Vesting

Even after performance goals are met, companies may impose a holding or service period before shares are fully vested and transferable.

5. Dividend Equivalents

While you typically don't receive dividends during the performance period, some plans credit dividend equivalents that are paid out if and when the award vests.

🧠 Example: EPS-Based Performance Share Grant

Imagine your company grants you 2,000 PSUs with a three-year performance period tied to earnings per share (EPS) growth:

Year Target EPS Actual EPS Payout Multiplier
2023 $5.00 $5.30 +6%
2024 $5.50 $5.80 +5%
2025 $6.00 $6.40 +7%

Cumulative EPS growth = 18%, versus a target of 15%. That places results at 120% of the goal, earning a 1.2x multiplier.

You'd receive 2,400 shares (2,000 × 1.2) at the end of the cycle, assuming continued employment.

🔄 Performance Shares vs. Restricted Stock and RSUs

It's easy to confuse performance shares with RSUs or restricted stock, but there are key distinctions that affect both value and risk.

Feature Restricted Stock / RSUs Performance Shares (PSUs)
Issued at Grant Yes (restricted until vesting) No (earned upon goal achievement)
Vesting Trigger Time or continued service Company performance metrics
Value Certainty Always some value if stock > $0 May be worth zero if goals are missed
Primary Purpose Retention Pay-for-performance alignment
Investor View Seen as guaranteed equity Seen as a performance-driven reward

Bottom line: RSUs reward you for staying. Performance shares reward you for results.

🧩 The Gray Zone: Performance-Based Restricted Stock

Not all companies cleanly separate “performance shares” from “restricted stock with performance vesting.”

For instance:

  • Performance-Contingent Restricted Stock grants shares upfront but delays vesting until performance goals are met.
  • Performance-Accelerated Restricted Stock vests over time but can vest early if performance triggers are hit.

Some companies even label these as “performance shares” in filings, blurring the terminology.

For example, a proxy statement might read:

“Executives receive restricted stock that vests only if three-year cumulative EPS targets are achieved. We refer to these as performance shares.”

This reinforces the need to review your specific grant agreement, not just the summary, to understand vesting terms, measurement mechanics, and payout conditions.

📈 Why Companies Love Performance Shares

  1. Investor Alignment
    Investors want executives to be rewarded for creating real shareholder value, not just for staying employed or riding a bull market.
    Performance shares link compensation to metrics that investors care about, such as profit growth, returns on capital, and peer-relative stock performance.

  2. Governance Optics
    Boards and compensation committees like performance shares because they demonstrate responsible pay design. Proxy advisory firms such as ISS and Glass Lewis also favor performance-based awards.

  3. Recruitment & Retention
    While stock options and RSUs remain important, performance shares add a long-term incentive that aligns leadership behavior with sustainable results.

  4. Tax & Accounting Advantages
    Under FASB ASC 718 (formerly FAS 123R), companies record a fixed expense at the grant date based on fair value, rather than using variable accounting. If goals aren't met, the expense can be reversed, improving earnings optics.
    This accounting predictability has fueled the widespread adoption of PSUs.

  5. Perceived “Better Deal” Than Options
    When modeled using realistic stock growth assumptions, target-level PSUs often have higher after-tax value than comparable stock options.
    Executives don't need massive share-price appreciation to earn value; just solid, measurable company performance.

💡 Financial Planning Considerations

For executives and key employees, performance shares can represent significant potential upside but also complexity. Here's how to think strategically:

  1. Scenario Modeling
    Work with your advisor to model best-case, target, and below-threshold outcomes. This helps quantify the impact of PSUs on your long-term wealth plan.

  2. Diversification Planning
    Since payout depends on company performance, your concentration risk may already be high. Plan early for how you'll diversify once shares vest and settle.

  3. Tax Timing
    Performance shares are typically taxed as ordinary income when they vest and deliver, based on the fair market value of the shares at that time. No Section 83(b) election applies because shares aren't granted upfront. Your advisor should work to optimize withholding, estimated payments, and the timing of sales.

  4. Retention Periods
    Some companies impose a post-vesting holding requirement (e.g., 1 year or until a multiple of salary is held in company stock). Make sure you understand these restrictions before assuming liquidity.

  5. Exit or M&A Scenarios
    Review what happens to unvested PSUs in a merger or acquisition; they may accelerate, convert, or be forfeited depending on the plan's “change-in-control” provisions.

🌎 The Global Trend

Outside the U.S., particularly in the U.K. and Europe, performance shares have long been a standard component of executive pay programs. U.S. companies have since followed suit, making PSUs almost mandatory for senior leadership at public firms.

Now, mid-level executives and high-impact contributors are also receiving performance shares, bringing this once “C-suite only” benefit to a broader professional base.

🧭 Key Takeaways

  • Performance shares tie pay to performance, not tenure.
  • They can offer a greater upside than RSUs or options, but also carry a risk of zero payout.
  • Each company's plan is different; your grant agreement defines the rules.
  • Taxation occurs at vesting/delivery, not grant.
  • These awards signal alignment between executives, investors, and long-term corporate goals.

For professionals navigating complex compensation packages, particularly those that combine RSUs, stock options, and PSUs, integrated planning across tax, investment, and equity strategy is crucial.

At VIP Wealth Advisors, we help clients translate these complex structures into actionable financial decisions, so your equity compensation works as hard as you do.

🏁 Takeaway: Make Performance Work for You

Performance shares are redefining how executives and professionals are rewarded, shifting the focus from stock price appreciation to sustainable business performance.

Understanding how your PSUs fit into your broader financial picture, including taxes, diversification, and retirement goals, can unlock their full potential.

At VIP Wealth Advisors, we specialize in helping high-income professionals and executives integrate equity compensation into a cohesive wealth strategy. If your compensation package includes performance shares, RSUs, or stock options, we can help you translate those complex grants into a clear financial roadmap.

💬 Performance Share FAQs

Q: What's the difference between PSUs and RSUs?
A: RSUs vest based on time or continued employment, while PSUs vest based on company performance metrics such as EPS growth or TSR. RSUs always have some value if the stock price is positive; PSUs can pay out zero if the goals are not met.
Q: How are performance shares taxed?
A: You're taxed when shares are delivered (after performance goals are met and vesting occurs). The fair market value is treated as ordinary income, subject to federal, state, and payroll taxes. Future appreciation is capital gain when you sell the shares.
Q: What happens if I leave the company before performance shares vest?
A: Generally, unvested performance shares are forfeited. However, plans may include special provisions for retirement, disability, death, or layoff, sometimes allowing prorated vesting.
Q: Can PSUs be paid in cash instead of stock?
A: Yes. Some companies issue performance units that represent a dollar value rather than share count, with payout in cash, stock, or a mix of both.
Q: Do performance shares pay dividends?
A: Usually not during the performance period. However, some plans credit dividend equivalents, which are paid only if the shares ultimately vest.
Q: Are PSUs better than stock options?
A: It depends on the company's performance. PSUs typically provide more consistent value across a range of outcomes, while options offer higher upside if the stock soars. A balanced mix can provide optimal long-term incentive alignment.

📊 Turn PSUs Into A Real Plan

We help tech professionals, executives, and equity-rich leaders translate performance awards into a tax-smart, diversified wealth strategy.

• Award modeling: 0%–200% scenarios
• Tax optimization at delivery
• Diversification and liquidity planning
• Change-in-control & holding rules review
📅 Book Your VIP Planning Call
No asset minimums, no product pushing - just modern, strategic advice for real life.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Mark Stancato, CFP®, EA, ECA, CRPS®

Mark Stancato, CFP®, EA, ECA, CRPS® has over 20 years of experience advising high-net-worth clients, including tech executives, real estate investors, and entertainment professionals. He specializes in tax strategy, equity compensation, and multi-stream income planning—offering white-glove guidance and highly personalized financial solutions.

Insights Via Email

VIP Financial Insights

Subscribe to our Financial Insights alerts and be notified by email as soon as new articles are published.